Hello dear
Welcome To Four Brothers Pizza Inn
Four Brothers Pizza Inn, located in Dover Plains, NY, is a beloved dining destination known for its warm, homey atmosphere and consistently delicious food. Customers rave about the friendly service and the inviting decor, making it a perfect spot for families and friends. Signature dishes like the Brothers special pizza showcase high-quality ingredients that delight diners. Whether you’re stopping in after a hike at nearby Dover Stone Church or enjoying a cozy meal with loved ones, Four Brothers Pizza Inn stands out for its impeccable service and food. After nearly two decades of excellence, it remains a staple for both locals and visitors alike.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Chicken Wings
Chicken Fingers
US$8.95Famous Greek Salad
US$5.50
Tossed Salad
US$4.95Famous Greek Salad
Tossed Salad
Pasta with Housemade Marinara Sauce
US$10.95Pasta with Sausage
US$12.95Farmers Burger
US$11.95 About
Four Brothers Pizza Inn
Welcome to the culinary delight that is Four Brothers Pizza Inn, nestled in the heart of Dover Plains, New York. Located at 3189 NY-22, this charming eatery is not just a pizza place; it’s a community favorite that beckons pizza enthusiasts and families alike. Whether you’re looking for a cozy diner vibe or a friendly atmosphere, Four Brothers Pizza Inn hits all the right notes.
As a food reviewer, I can’t help but be drawn to the warm ambiance and inviting decor that embellishes the restaurant's walls. It’s evident from the moment you step inside that the owners have dedicated their passion to creating a welcoming environment. The thoughtful decor, paired with stellar reviews, showcases a venue where quality food and exceptional service go hand in hand.
Guests have lauded the menu, particularly the Brothers Special Pizza, celebrated for its delightful flavors and freshness. Frequent patrons like Vanna Vazouras, who has been dining here for over 20 years, rave about the consistent quality and the friendly smiles that greet them at the door. It’s a place where every meal feels like a special occasion. According to Emily Rose, a first-time visitor, the food not only satisfied her taste but also left her with a lasting impression, stating it was a "homey place to be." This sentiment encapsulates the heart of Four Brothers Pizza Inn.
Quality is a hallmark of this establishment. As Nikki Incorvaia pointed out, you can taste the superior products used in their dishes. Whether you choose a small cheese pizza or a fresh Greek salad, you're guaranteed to encounter fresh, high-quality ingredients. With options that cater to both dine-in and takeout, Four Brothers stands out as a dependable choice for any meal occasion.
If you’re in the area, make sure to stop by and indulge in the delightful offerings at Four Brothers Pizza Inn. With friendly service, a menu brimming with flavor, and an atmosphere that feels like home, it is a culinary gem you won’t want to miss.
For inquiries or to place an order, you can reach them at +1 845-877-3662. Trust me, after one visit, Four Brothers Pizza Inn will likely become your go-to spot too!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Love this restaurant, pretty decor on the wall and displays. Food is good taste, service is great! Definitely come back ”
“ Always good...had the Brothers special pizza. Service was good, friendly and kind. Would recommend as a nice clean family place. ”
“ I’ve never been to a Four Brothers before. Was driving by and it looked cozy from the road so we decided to stop for a bite to eat. Food was delicious. The people were really nice. It felt like such a homey place to be. I live closer to the one in Mahopac but will definitely be back to this location specifically. I just wanted to say thanks for the great meal and a nice little dining experience! We left very happy. ”
“ I love Four Brothers Pizza!!! They use very good quality product and it shows. I had a small cheese pizza and my husband had a Greek Salad. It is close to Dover Stone Church where I want to go hiking so we will be back soon. ”
“ Four Brothers is our go to restaurant. The food is always impeccable and the service is great. Their pizza is always consistent and we are always greeted at the door with a smile. We have been coming here for 20 years and will continue to have four brothers as our staple for dining and takeout! ”
“ My family and I love this place. Their pizza is SO delicious and they have a crispy chicken wrap that is the only thing I want to eat while I’m currently pregnant. My husband tried their wrap with greek dressing tonight and the dressing was AMAZING. The people who work there are always so nice. I am shocked there are any negative reviews. Can’t wait to come back soon! ”
“ Delicious food, attentive staff and easily accessible location ”
“ Delicious food!! We had the small pizza (before hiking for extra energy) and we ordered the small one and that served 2 adults! You can choose the toppings. The base is not thin! I recommendSuper friendly staff! The place is simple, clean and inviting. ”